Friday, September 23, 2011

Dumbest Generation Yet? Maybe..

Like Bauerlein says, we may be the "dumbest generation".  As appalling as some of his accusations are, they are not without merit.  Most of us get sucked into facebook, twitter and google+ without even realizing it.  If we aren't gamers, we can sit back and stigmatize them, but in essence we are doing the same thing with social networking.  We get so caught up in whats going on online that we forget to live our lives and learn the very things that are right in front of us.  Instead of learning hands on from our parents how to cook or clean a tough stain we deem ourselves too busy.  So when we need to know something we rely on our computers, smart phones and iPads to give us the information.  Forget memorizing recipes, you can pull them up with nothing more than a few clicks.  Oh you don't understand mile markers along the highway, sure just put it in your GPS. All of the technology available today doesn't require us to think critically or even think at all.  The information is at our finger tips, instead of up in our brains.  

So with all of that said, who is to blame?

Sure some of the blame rests on our shoulders ( as Gen Y), but it doesn't seem that the finger can be pointed at only one group/generation.  In Drutmans LA Times Article, he says "... it reflects not stupidity, but a failure of the school system and of society(which is run by grown-ups)..." He couldn't be more on point. Judging this 'stupidity' from the outside things may look very two dimensional, but being in this "dumbest generation" allows for a more three-dimensional view.  It's easy for other generations to simply say 'its Gen Y's fault', since they aren't in our position they don't realize how their actions may also have affected us and shaped our generation.  Bauerlein provided us with some statistics in his interview: the younger generation spends on average six hours a week studying and 9 hours a week social networking.  This should cause a knee jerk reaction to parents; during welcoming day/orientation at Shippensburg, i know they told my parents that for each hour of instruction i should be spending at least three hours out of class studying and working with the material.  If adults were holding themselves to a higher standard and instead of trying to be our 'friends', we could learn the things older generations value.  

Technology, as i referenced above allows the continuation of our ignorance of the world around us.  We know where to find it, as the La Times article states, so we don't pay to much mind to it when we 'learn' it in class, or hear about it when we are walking down the street.  I know that we are all guilty of that, I am no exception.  I also find it hypocritical of older generations to knock the amount of time we spend on the internet though.  All of my classes now have online components, so even if i wasn't 'obsessed' with technology as is suggested by Bauerlein, I cant escape it.  The reason.tv interview mentions that the web wouldn't be bad if kids were surfing sites such as the Smithsonian Institute's, but being online for anything such as classes, only adds to the temptation to surf.  So if we shouldn't be surfing the web, they shouldn't be surrounding us with entrancing media.  

Overall, we may be the dumbest generation as of yet, but we will not remain the dumbest generation for long.  If we are uneducated in worldly happenings and household matters, our kids won't be either.  If the trend isn't stopped soon, every successive generation will be less intelligent than the last.  

5 comments:

  1. I really like your comment about information being at our fingertips instead of our brains, I agree. Also I like your sentence about how you say you can't really point the finger at a specific group, you can't, I also feel that its not a a specific group's fault. I do agree that we need to realize what is going on with us and I think we simply need to accept that fact that we are dumb in Bauerliens sense of the definition. Like I commented on several other blogs, we need to go out and grab the opportunities that are available to us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also agree that we utilize the interent and techonology way too much instead of just using our common sense and using information we already know. I think about times in math class when I have a simple addition problem, and even though I know I can do in my head, I use my calculator. I think that there is no one to blame and we all should just accept the fact that times have changed and this is how the world is now. There is no sense in pointing fingers and trying to figure out who is the "dumbest". We are all aboard this sinking ship, and it not going to help running around screaming at each other about whose fault it is.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that the generations following us will be even more ignorant that our generation. Like you stated, if we don't learn how to take in the world around us, how are we going to teach our children or grandchildren? I feel as though our generation is smart when it comes to technology and adapting to the newest trend, but I also feel that some of our generation lacks ambition and drive. If we were more concerned with learning that the newest trend, I feel as though the generations before us would look at us in a whole new way. (Not saying all of our generation is obsessed with new technology or new trends)

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree anything we want to know about we can just look it up. This can be both a good and bad thing. I think it does more harm though because instead of using our brains for information we rather take the easy way out and look it up online. I think each generations has an upper hand on the other in terms of knowledge. I remember when my grand mom looked at my math homework and was confused. With homework and readings done on-line its so tempting to just click an extra tab and log into twitter or Facebook to socialize.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't think it is as easy to say that every generation after us could very likely be the dumbest generation. Not every child with parents who are of below average IQ are of that IQ or lower. It is just as likely that a generation of dumb people (not saying we're the dumbest generation, mind you) would be just as dumb or more dumb.

    ReplyDelete